3DS Performance | Country Metrics
United States 3DS metrics
3D Secure (3DS) hasn't become the industry standard in the US the way it has in the EU and other mandated markets. Part of that traces back to the original version of the protocol (3DS1), which was slow and unfriendly to use. It redirected customers to unfamiliar pages and asked them to enter static passwords, which led to abandoned checkouts and a lasting hesitancy toward 3DS adoption in the US. This is changing though.
3DS2 overhauled the protocol with support for biometric authentication, mobile apps, and one-time passcodes, along with a risk-based model that lets low-risk purchases pass without a challenge (often referred to as frictionless). Combined with the surge in digital commerce and mobile payments since the pandemic, rising fraud and chargeback losses in card-not-present transactions, and pressure from global partners and consumers already used to these authentication standards elsewhere, momentum behind 3DS adoption in the US is building, even though it isn't mandatory.
One common misconception is that issuer support for 3DS is limited in the US. In practice, most major US issuers already support it, and very few authentication attempts fail because a card isn't enrolled. So it's not that there's a lack of support, it's that 3DS just isn't being used.
The rest of this post covers 3DS metrics in the US based on the traffic we see through our platform. If you want more information about implementing 3DS in the US, we wrote about it extensively.
The data below reflects 3DS sessions for customer initiated transactions (CIT) through Evervault's own platform in the US, between January 1st, 2026 and June 30th, 2026. Some results were excluded where data was incomplete or insufficient, or where sessions were configured to fail the challenge outright to reduce customer friction.
Metric descriptions
Metric | Description |
|---|---|
Success rate | The percentage of 3DS sessions that successfully authenticated the cardholder through a frictionless or challenge flow (successful authentications divided by the total number of frictionless and challenge sessions). |
Challenge / frictionless / attempt split | Of all sessions, the percentage that went through a challenge flow, the percentage that went through a frictionless flow, and the percentage resolved through an attempt flow. Attempt flows are a network-level fallback (e.g., Visa's Attempts Server) used when the issuer couldn't perform full authentication. It's not a genuine authentication decision by the issuer, so we report it separately. |
Challenge flow success rate | Of the sessions that went through a challenge flow, the percentage that successfully authenticated the cardholder. |
P50 time to completion | The median: 50% of challenge flows resolved faster than this, and 50% took longer. |
P75 time to completion | 75% of challenge flows resolved faster than this, and 25% took longer. Useful alongside P50 for seeing how quickly things start to slow down beyond the typical case. |
P95 time to completion | 95% of challenge flows resolved faster than this value. It captures how long the slowest (but still common) sessions take, without being distorted by the most extreme handful of outliers. |
Percentiles are used instead of a single average for time to completion. Completion times vary a lot depending on the authentication method, the cardholder, and the ACS. A single average would hide the gap between typical "fast" sessions and "slower" but still valid sessions. We also excluded sessions that took longer than 5 minutes to resolve. Most challenge flows are completed faster than that, and the extreme outliers (10-30+ minutes) heavily skewed the results.
Country metrics
In the US, the 3DS success rate has been around 98.6%. Across all sessions, 80.73% followed a frictionless flow, 7.3% followed a challenge flow, and 11.97% were resolved through an attempt flow. When challenges did occur, they typically resolved in 21 seconds, with 95% resolving within 84 seconds.
Metric | Value |
|---|---|
Success rate | 98.6% |
Challenge / frictionless / attempt split | 7.3% / 80.73% / 11.97% |
Challenge flow success rate | 82.6% |
Time to completion for challenge flows (P50 / P75 / P95) | 21s / 34s / 84s |
Top five 3DS failure reasons
These are the top five failure reasons that we see. These are our own human readable error codes, which are easier to parse than the raw 3DS protocol statuses.
Rank | Failure reason | Description |
|---|---|---|
1 |
| Typically this is due to the cardholder failing to provide the correct 3DS authentication details. This transaction should be considered as potentially fraudulent. |
2 |
| The cardholder cancelled the transaction. |
3 |
| The authentication timed out. This is likely because the cardholder abandoned the transaction. |
4 |
| Treat this similar to |
5 |
| The transaction data that was sent was invalid or incomplete. Double check the request to make sure the correct data is sent. |
We excluded challenge-required from this list because it's not a genuine failure. It reflects sessions where a challenge was required but the session was set to fail-on-challenge to avoid forcing the cardholder through the challenge flow.
Issuer metrics
Issuer enrollment has been at 99.28% with 0.01% of transactions failing because the cards themselves aren't enrolled.
Issuer | Success rate | Challenge / frictionless / attempt split | Time to completion for challenge flows (P50 / P75 / P95) |
|---|---|---|---|
Jpmorgan Chase Bank N.A. | 100.0% | 0% / 99.96% / 0.04% | — |
Jpmorgan Chase Bank N.A. - Debit | 100.0% | 0% / 99.96% / 0.04% | — |
Varo Bank, National Association | 100.0% | 0% / 7.47% / 92.53% | — |
Cross River Bank | 99.9% | 1.04% / 94.21% / 4.75% | 24s / 38s / 134s |
Pathward, National Association | 99.9% | 0.03% / 21.32% / 78.65% | 3s / 6s / 12s |
Stride Bank, National Association | 99.6% | 3.48% / 96.08% / 0.44% | 22s / 40s / 126s |
The Bancorp Bank, National Association | 99.5% | 3.52% / 92.89% / 3.59% | 23s / 44s / 141s |
Pathward, N.A. | 99.4% | 0.21% / 33.09% / 66.71% | 2s / 3s / 18s |
Sutton Bank | 99.1% | 3.34% / 95.38% / 1.28% | 18s / 31s / 92s |
Coastal Community Bank | 99.0% | 0.69% / 7.9% / 91.4% | 17s / 27s / 67s |
Green Dot Bank Dba Bonneville Bank | 99.0% | 2.39% / 33.62% / 63.98% | 23s / 36s / 89s |
The Bancorp Bank National Association | 98.8% | 13.49% / 85.78% / 0.73% | 14s / 21s / 50s |
Navy Federal Credit Union | 98.7% | 10.46% / 89.26% / 0.28% | 26s / 36s / 78s |
Regions Bank | 98.0% | 2.17% / 97.78% / 0.04% | 9s / 17s / 27s |
Pnc Bank, National Association | 97.7% | 15.18% / 84.7% / 0.12% | 16s / 25s / 61s |
Bank Of America, National Association | 97.3% | 15.61% / 84.15% / 0.24% | 17s / 25s / 58s |
U.S. Bank National Association | 96.8% | 15.71% / 83.92% / 0.37% | 12s / 20s / 56s |
Wells Fargo Bank, National Association | 96.1% | 20.01% / 79.74% / 0.25% | 35s / 48s / 95s |
Capital One, National Association | 95.3% | 29.11% / 68.67% / 2.27% | 25s / 38s / 89s |
Community Federal Savings Bank | 92.2% | 3.86% / 10.21% / 85.93% | 28s / 56s / 144s |
Card brand metrics
Visa accounts for the majority of 3DS volume in the US at 78.13%. Success rates are broadly consistent across all four brands (96.5% to 98.9%), but Discover relies far more heavily on challenge flows than the other three (40.98% of its sessions, versus under 20% for Visa, Mastercard, and American Express).
Card brand | % of volume | Success rate | Challenge / frictionless / attempt split | Time to completion for challenge flows (P50 / P75 / P95) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Visa | 78.13% | 98.9% | 5.41% / 86.33% / 8.26% | 23s / 36s / 93s |
Mastercard | 20.34% | 97.8% | 12.79% / 60.13% / 27.09% | 19s / 30s / 73s |
Discover | 0.79% | 96.5% | 40.98% / 58.91% / 0.11% | 21s / 29s / 59s |
American Express | 0.74% | 97.2% | 19.81% / 79.38% / 0.82% | 24s / 41s / 110s |
US vs. Canada and Mexico
The US leads both Canada and Mexico on success rate, though all three are within about 4%. Canada and Mexico both lean more heavily on challenge flows than the US, and Canada's challenge flow success rate (86.2%) runs ahead of both the US (82.6%) and Mexico (69.0%).
Metric | US | CA | MX |
|---|---|---|---|
Success rate | 98.6% | 96.6% | 94.4% |
Challenge / frictionless / attempt split | 7.3% / 80.73% / 11.97% | 42.9% / 54.65% / 2.45% | 17.27% / 78.01% / 4.72% |
Challenge flow success rate | 82.6% | 86.2% | 69.0% |
Time to completion for challenge flows (P50 / P75 / P95) | 21s / 34s / 84s | 26s / 42s / 103s | 26s / 45s / 121s |
US vs. the global average
Against the global average, the US's success rate runs slightly ahead. Globally, 3DS relies more on challenge flows than in the US, and those challenges succeed at a somewhat lower rate globally than in the US.
Metric | US | Global average |
|---|---|---|
Success rate | 98.6% | 95.7% |
Challenge / frictionless / attempt split | 7.3% / 80.73% / 11.97% | 22.67% / 68.36% / 8.97% |
Challenge flow success rate | 82.6% | 81.8% |
Time to completion for challenge flows (P50 / P75 / P95) | 21s / 34s / 84s | 25s / 40s / 106s |
Evervault's universal 3DS solution
If you're looking to add 3D Secure, or are having issues with your current provider, check out Evervault's 3DS solution. It's a single integration that lets you trigger 3DS on any transaction across all your payment processors.
This data reflects 3DS sessions processed through Evervault's platform only, and may not represent the broader market. It's shared for general information purposes only.
© 2026 Evervault Inc. All rights reserved.